PDA

View Full Version : Google to Update Ad Quality Scoring



Lev
February 15th, 2007, 12:12 PM
By Kevin Newcomb | February 15, 2007

Google announced today that it will be updating its ad ranking algorithm for AdWords, and making that process a bit more transparent for advertisers.

Before the end of the month, Google plans to implement an improved quality-based bidding system, updating the current AdRank algorithm that first launched in August 2005, and has been updated consistently since then. The last major updates came in December 2005, and again in July 2006. Enhancements came the in the form of landing page quality scoring additions that left many advertisers upset with Google's lack of information regarding how that quality score was reached.

The changes this time around will not add new elements to the score, as much as change the weight that each component receives in the scoring, Nicholas Fox, senior business product manager for ad quality, told ClickZ News.

"This is a change to the algorithm itself, updating what we call 'prediction confidence' to improve the accuracy in determining quality score in cases where we have less data," Fox said. In effect, Google is becoming more lenient with ads that it knows nothing about, but could become stricter with ads once it has gathered some data, he said.

The net effect could be the re-activation of many keywords that were previously deactivated when their minimum bids had risen above the advertiser's desired cost-per-click (CPC) bid. As those minimum bids are recalculated under the new algorithm and fall below the advertiser's bid threshold, those ads will be reactivated, unless the advertiser deactivates them or lowers their bids below the new threshold. In other cases, certain ads will be treated more harshly under the new algorithm, and their minimum bids will increase.

To help advertisers prepare for the changes, Google is adding a new quality score column to the advertiser's AdWords account interface. Beginning Thursday, advertisers will be allowed to activate the new column on their accounts, and begin making plans for the new algorithm.

The tool will show advertisers an estimate of their ad's quality -- in general terms like "great," "ok" or "poor" -- as well as the estimated minimum bids associated with them. The scores and bid estimates will be updated at least daily, with more frequent updates in certain categories.

"Advertisers have asked us to provide more transparency into the process, and now we're able to provide that visibility," Fox said. "This is the first step of many in that direction that you'll see in the next few months."

Though Google was the first major search engine to incorporate a quality score in its ad ranking algorithm, it has since been followed by Microsoft's adCenter and Yahoo's Panama platforms, both of which include a quality metric with varying degrees of transparency.

http://www.clickz.com/showPage.html?page=3624993

BoogalooDude
February 15th, 2007, 02:51 PM
Yup, came onto the forum to post this very story. Here comes the next Google Slap.

I'd still like to see exactly how that quality score is reached, I can figure out on my own whether the keyword is 'poor' or 'good' or whatever just from the bid price, clik thru rate, average position etc

Hope there's more to it than a column with 'poor' 'good' and 'great' rankings.....

Miles Baker
February 15th, 2007, 03:36 PM
Could be good or bad, I suppose we'll just have to wait and see.

ArtColombia
February 15th, 2007, 11:44 PM
I see it as good, so far I have a lot of faith in the G business model... sure a G slap hits hard, makes things tougher, but I do believe that they are improving their business model and weeding out the bullshitters. Any correct feedback to advertisers is a good thing, donīt you think?

hgarcia0509
February 16th, 2007, 01:02 AM
Yes!! I love Google updates. Everytime they do them, I end up making more money. :lol:

H Garcia

TrustNo1
February 16th, 2007, 02:24 AM
You can already see it. Probably more than 1 way to get there but I went to my Ad Group, clicked Customize Columns and you can click Show Quality Score. It will say Great or Ok and give you the minimum bid. Last time I got hit by the $10 and $15 bids but checking right now I have minimums with Great showing next to it with some bids as low as 2 and 3 cents. So far it looks great.

Trudat
February 16th, 2007, 02:35 AM
Wow, I didn't know about that. Thanks Trust. Most of mine are Great/OK, though I found some poor (on paused campaigns thank god, so I guess I stopped them for a reason lol). Most min CPC are around .03 and .04, so I need to work on that. I have a few $.01 though, so that's cool. lol

I have yet to be (severely?) hurt by a Google Slap. Bring 'em on!

dppls
February 16th, 2007, 12:11 PM
Wow, I didn't know about that. Thanks Trust. Most of mine are Great/OK, though I found some poor (on paused campaigns thank god, so I guess I stopped them for a reason lol). Most min CPC are around .03 and .04, so I need to work on that. I have a few $.01 though, so that's cool. lol

I have yet to be (severely?) hurt by a Google Slap. Bring 'em on!

I think it's cool to have the Great, good and poor rating etc...

It will, as said in the article, be more transparent for all the users...
I doubt someone will put out a poor advert... Well I am hoping...

Trudat
February 16th, 2007, 12:13 PM
Man, they brought it on too much. Roughly half my ads got pwned to one degree or another. Only one wasn't at all affected.

Biff_Tiberius_Farnsworth
February 16th, 2007, 03:59 PM
I had a domain full of one page sites that got slapped last summer. There were a dozen or so pure arbitrage pages on there that deserved it (if you weren't playing the arbitrage game before 'smart pricing' and 'quality score' then you were leaving easy money on the table) but they slapped the whole domain. Moved the other pages (I have lots of domains) and a week later I was back to normal (except for the $3000 to $5000 per month on the arbitrage stuff).

After seeing this new update, I went back to that domain's ad groups (which were just paused) and when I resumed them they were back to pre slap rates except for the arbitrage, they are still $10 per click so I think that this is a step in the right direction.

On a side note, my Adwords spending is waaaaayyy down this year. If I told you the numbers you probably wouldn't believe me. It was a combination of rising costs per click and plummeting conversion rates. I now get the bulk of my traffic for free YAY! (it took almost a year of tedious boring work) and get great conversions on Panama. Adcenter still sucks but I keep a few fingers in that pie in case it changes.

~B

ArtColombia
February 16th, 2007, 08:04 PM
Biff: what kind of arbitrage do you mean? AdSense? or is there some other way to apply arbitrage tactics in AM?

Biff_Tiberius_Farnsworth
February 16th, 2007, 08:50 PM
Hi Art. Adsense and YPN arbitrage.

~B